Simplicity Maternity Dress & Top 1469

A review of Simplicity Maternity Dress & Top 1469 (out of print)


Reviewed by Anna-Jo on 1st November, 2016

This is a simple empire line knit top with an outer bodice you can stretch down, with an inner bodice that has cut outs for nursing access. It would be pretty easy to make it without that access, though, if you had no need for it.

I cut a size S, although my measurements put me more towards the M sizing, as I’ve learnt that Big 4 pattern sizing is always too generous for my liking. As I was seaming with my overlocker I did, however, taper out to the edge of the seam allowance over the hips, adding in just a touch more ease.

I used a lightweight maroon viscose jersey along with the same fabric in a black and white polka dot print for the contrast pieces. It’s an incredibly slinky fabric which drapes beautifully, but is a complete bugger to sew.

I made a few changes to the original pattern. First up, since I’d already lost the worst of the baby tummy, I decided to forgo the extra fabric in the front lower bodice–basically I just cut the back piece twice. This might have been a mistake as the fabric is so clingy it shows every bulge, reminding me I really do need to make the effort to go running! Also, it shows everything underneath, from bra-straps to jeans fastenings. Hence jeggings?

And as you can also see from the side and back views, I really should have done something to stop it riding up at the back. I’m not sure if I need a swayback adjustment, or if I need more fabric to cover my ample behind.

I went a bit wild with the polka dot fabric, using it in way more places than the pattern suggested. This was partly because I like polka dots, but mainly because this was really designed to be a wearable toile, and I didn’t have enough of the maroon jersey to cut all the pieces.

As for the instructions, they were easy to follow but pretty basic and I wasn’t entirely sure about the ways they suggested to finish the edges (folding over and zig-zagging). I finished the curved inner bodice edges with just a serged edge as I didn’t want any bulk to show through and give away the fact it was a nursing top. There was no clear elastic specified at all, but I added it to the shoulder seams, as well as along the neckline of both the outer and inner bodice pieces. In hindsight, this might have been a mistake as I think I stretched the elastic slightly along the bodice edge, and ended up with some slight gathering there which you might be able to see in the pictures.

As I wasn’t getting on well with the zig-zagging, and as my attempts at twin needle stitching had gone horribly wrong on this same fabric for my original t-shirt (tunnelling galore!), I decided to try something different for finishing the armholes and hem. For some reason I was wary of trying a bound edge for the first time, so I tried a narrow rolled edge on the overlocker, with a little lettuce leaf crinkling. It’s one of my favourite finishes for delicate wovens, but I have to admit I’m not quite so enamoured with it on this knit fabric.

Verdict? Well, although I have a few reservations about the clinginess of the fabric, the colour choice and the methods used to finish the edges, I still wear this top pretty much whenever it comes back out of the laundry. It fills a much needed hole in my wardrobe: a dressy yet casual sleeveless top suitable for discreet breastfeeding.

Read the review in full on my blog: